Capitalism that Works for Everyone
Private ownership of property and production, the profit motive, free markets and free trade–capitalism is an economic system and ideology. It made America the world superpower. The rise of capitalism promoted an 80 percent reduction in world poverty in less than four decades led by a 97 percent reduction in East Asia (as shown below).
The bad news is that capitalism is not working very well for most Americans. As David Leonhart illustrated, poor and middle class, who used to see the benefits from income growth, are now largely getting the scraps, left behind by the one percent, or really, the 0.001 percent.
“I think the greatest issue of our time is the disparity of wealth and the problems that exist for the lower 40 percent of the population,” said Ray Dalio, founder of Bridgewater Associates. Bridgewater is the world’s largest hedge fund, which about $160 billion in assets. According to Forbes, Dalio himself is worth about $17 billion.
“If you carve out that lower 40 percent, not only has there been no income growth, but death rates are rising because of opiate use, suicide, and because they’re losing jobs,” Dalio said. “This is the biggest issue of our time—the biggest economic issue, the biggest political issue, and the biggest social issue.”
Warren Buffett said “You really shouldn’t have an economy with over $50,000 in GDP per person and have lots of people living in poverty who are willing to work. I mean, that makes no sense and we need governmental policies to correct that.”
“Capitalism does not self-correct toward greater equality—that is, excess wealth concentration can have a snowball effect if left unchecked,” said Bill Gates.
Inequality Gets Worse From Here
Our new report on the future of work and learning illustrated how the combination of artificial intelligence, big data and enabling technologies like robotics are changing the employment landscape fast.
A PwC report predicts that more than a third of jobs could be at risk by 2030. A new McKinsey report says 400 to 800 million people will be looking for work (some predict bigger losses starting next year).
The combination of AI, big data and new enabling technologies is creating new jobs but most are small technical niches that are even harder to predict than displacement which will vary by sector and geography.
“Workers who have steadily lost access to the economy as digital processes replace them have a sense of things falling apart, and a quiet anger about immigration, inequality and arrogant elites,” said Brian Arthur, an external professor at the Santa Fe Institute.
The angst that fueled the 2016 election only gets worse from here. Financial returns are rapidly shifting from labor to capital–the people that own and finance the robots win in the automation economy.
Arthur notes that we’re at the end of the old production economy driven by free-market economics and old measures of growth and in a distribution economy where it’s all about who has access to what’s produced. From here on out, it’s all about sharing–who has access to the benefits and income produced by exponential technology–and that’s a political problem.
Learning to Share
Psychology (and Calvinism) suggest that young children are inherently selfish. Biology seems to boost the capacity for empathy by age six or seven leading to early-stage altruism or at least a sense of fairness. Early attitudes and habits can be influenced by adults that create terms of engagement and model fairness and generosity.
Middle-grade students learn to collaborate and work together on projects. Many high school students learn the importance of civic duty and community service.
Two current policy examples from Washington DC appear to look backward rather than forward and exacerbate hoarding rather than promoting sharing.
Not So Neutral Net. The FCC is set to vote December 14 to reverse Obama era regulations requiring internet providers to provide open access to their networks for all digital content.
The new rules would give network providers like Comcast, AT&T and Verizon new power to throttle distribution of certain content and charge more for better access. The proposed ruling is based on a bad definition and sets a bad precedent for sharing.
“Internet rights are civil rights,” said Jay Stanley, American Civil Liberties Union senior policy analyst. “Gutting net neutrality will have a devastating effect on free speech online. Without it, gateway corporations like Comcast, Verizon and AT&T will have too much power to mess with the free flow of information.”
School superintendents are concerned about the rollback of net neutrality regulations – concerns shared by SETDA and iNACOL.
There are arguments on both sides of this bill, but the proposed repeal appears to have little to do with the urge to share and the drive for equity.
Tax Cuts For the Wealthy. The Senate Republican tax plan gives substantial tax cuts and benefits to Americans earning more than $100,000 a year, while the nation’s poorest would be worse off, according to a report released Sunday by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office.
Whatever way the House and Senate reach a compromise tax bill, it is will exacerbate rather than narrow income inequality in America
Despite a 2016 election driven by populist angst, the DC dialog seems relevant to plutocrats rather than the broad interests of American’s facing automation economy.
The innovation economy will produce tremendous benefit and wealth–and both will be concentrated unless we decide otherwise. To extend US leadership in the innovation economy we’ll need to update our form of capitalism.
Our new paper on the future of work and learning suggests a couple solutions:
- Build a stronger social safety net. There are likely to be waves of dislocation and transition. Vulnerable populations will be at risk more frequently, putting new demands on social services including transitional housing, job training and mental-health supports.
- Build a new civic infrastructure. Given congressional gridlock, cities and states will be the laboratories of a new social compact in the U.S.–and they’ll need new public-private-philanthropic partnerships that frame challenges and run experiments on topics ranging from basic income protection, to job training, to autonomous vehicle regulation.
- Build lean public agencies. Taking a page from the Silicon Valley playbook, government entities will need to become more nimble by surveying and convening stakeholders to develop temporary agreements—a form of iterative social development. (The Finns changed their constitution to allow this form of active experimentation on basic income.)
- Build smart cities. Every region needs to develop learning ecosystems that help people skill up fast around distinctive capabilities. As we noted in Smart Cities That Work for Everyone, learning ecosystems include innovation leadership, public and private partnerships, aligned investment, talent pipelines and multiple affordable-learning entry points that recognize prior knowledge and certify new skills. Lots of small colleges will go bankrupt in the next few years, smart cities will find ways to transform these campuses into lifelong learning centers focused on emerging job clusters.
- Provoke youth contribution. There’s never been a better time to build an app, launch a campaign or start an organization. The ability to build large datasets around big problems and aim open source machine learning tools at them is unprecedented (like TensorFlow Lite and an iPhone X). Schools and community groups should invite young people into the problem solving, infrastructure building and agreement crafting process.
The debate in Washington is disappointing and irrelevant to the challenges we face. Cities and states will need to lead the way into the innovation economy. It starts with learning together about what’s happening and making decisions our kids will be proud of.
For more, see:
- Tell Kids to Get Good at Stuff Smart Machines Can’t Do (Yet)
- LRNG & John Legend Are Spreading Access to Quality Education
- On Beautiful Shared Places
- Preparing Today’s Student for Success Tomorrow Via Network
Stay in-the-know with all things EdTech and innovations in learning by signing up to receive the weekly Smart Update.
In contrast to a tax system for the automation economy, the proposed deal (according to Fareed Zakaria) may be the worst piece of legislation in a generation https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-gop-tax-bill-may-be-the-worst-piece-of-legislation-in-modern-history/2017/12/14/c1def814-e119-11e7-bbd0-9dfb2e37492a_story.html?utm_term=.140ce63e7972
Tom Vander Ark
Aug 2018 UN report says capitalism caused climate change and will continue to exacerbate the problem, they suggest a new economic approach that weighs long-term costs https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/climate-change-capitalism-economy_us_5b87bf0ce4b0cf7b00326edc
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be published. All fields are required.